Yeah, I think painting the door pillars back to black would look better IMO. (and replacing the brroken one!)
I used to have them white too back in the day.
Here's a pic of my coupe with a CTR style rear lip. Pretty cheap, and they look decent.
Here's a pic when I was rocking the Vision clears without the reflectors on them.
I like em, but, they were leaking water and foggin' up, so I took em off.
They look really good IMO.
Hope these pics help!