Yeah I've heard that a Y7 would be a pretty good bet. They're a bit thinner so you'd get that small amount of increased compression, they are made out of a better material, and they happen to be easier to remove / clean should the head be pulled again.
I haven't heard much about comparisons of the Z6 hg though. Either way you can't go wrong with oem..
Has anyone ever posted the results / benefits / downsides of using a thinner hg? It will increase compression, but how much really? And what are the real life gains associated?
I'm not knocking it, I'm just curious.
But two other things to consider:
1) Maybe increasing the compression (even if only slightly) might not be the best idea in an engine who's piston rings most likely aren't in the greatest condition? It could just be asking for more headaches down the road... Or it may be perfectly fine and your rings will hold up another 100,000 miles..
2) If you're reusing your head bolts, you're asking them to re-torque to factory specs (maybe even 5 ft/pounds more as some would suggest when reusing them), and now tighten even further into the block (since a thinner hg is, well.. thinner), and hold a little more compression...
Again this could mean nothing and everything could turn out perfectly fine, this is all just food for thought. But I haven't steered you wrong yet and I don't intend to do so now, I just want to see you get your car back on the road. You did after all say this was your primary source of transportation.. I wouldn't feel right if I didn't mention the possible benefits and/or downfalls.